REVIEW: Fruitvale Station


Courtesy of The Weinstein Company
There are some movies that, although they’re excellent, I’ve only seen once or twice because of the emotional gut-punch they inflict. For instance, while I appreciate films like Schindler’s List and Pan’s Labyrinth, on an artistic level, I don’t think I could put myself through the pain of watching them again.

Now I can add Fruitvale Station to that list. The fact-based drama from rookie filmmaker Ryan Coogler is so powerful, so heartbreaking that I was a total wreck by the time the credits rolled. I’m glad I saw it, but I don’t envision a scenario in which I’m ever emotionally equipped to repeat the experience.

In the early hours of New Year’s Day 2009, Oscar Grant III was involved in an altercation on a crowded Bay Area Rapid Transit train. When the train stopped at Oakland’s Fruitvale Station, BART police officers detained several people, including the 22-year-old Grant, on the platform. Then, while Grant was lying face down and unarmed on the ground with his hands cuffed behind him, an officer shot him in the back. He died a few hours later.

Dozens of witnesses captured the event on their phones and video cameras, sparking numerous protests, riots and criminal investigations. “Fruitvale Station” opens with some of the actual footage. The film then jumps back 24 hours so audiences can experience the last day of Grant’s life and witness the fateful choices he made (both good and bad) that led him to that platform.

For the most part, it’s an ordinary day. Grant (played by the phenomenal Michael B. Jordan) takes his daughter (Ariana Neal) to preschool, drops his girlfriend (Melonie Diaz) off at work and picks up a few things for his mother’s (Octavia Spencer) birthday dinner later that evening. However, the film also focuses on the aspects of Grant’s personality – his temper, his impulsiveness, etc. – that ultimately lead to tragedy.

The strength of Fruitvale Station is the result of two crucial decisions Coogler makes. First, his screenplay depicts Grant as an actual person with strengths and faults; he’s not a saint and he’s not a monster. Coogler realizes that all of us have made decisions that could’ve resulted in horrific consequences under the right circumstances. As such, he portrays the situation that led to Grant’s death as a perfect storm of actions, reactions, misunderstandings, profiling and flat-out terrible luck.

Secondly, Coogler picked a brilliant actor to play Grant, even writing the script with him in mind. Jordan – easily one of my favorite actors under the age of 30 – continues to build a staggering résumé, topping his work in The Wire, Friday Night Lights, Parenthood, and Chronicle with his poignant performance in Fruitvale Station. In a perfect world, it would earn him an Oscar nomination. There are also strong supporting performances from Diaz and Spencer (who also produced the film, along with Forest Whitaker).

Fruitvale Station isn’t exactly an enjoyable movie (though Jordan’s well-rounded depiction of Grant offers plenty of laughs and warm moments), but it’s an important one. If you’re of the mindset that film should be used to educate as well as entertain, it’s a must-see. Just bring a giant box of tissues.

Fruitvale Station is rated R for some violence, language throughout and some drug use.

Grade: B+

Comments