REVIEW: Prometheus

Courtesy of 20th Century Fox
Shrouded in mystery since the earliest stages of production, the main thing people want to know about Prometheus, Ridley Scott’s latest sci-fi thriller, is whether it’s connected to another little space movie the director made a few decades ago. I won’t bury the lede: yes, the film is a prequel to Alien. But you need to adjust your expectations.

As with most modern blockbusters, everything’s a setup for Prometheus 2. That means we won’t get answers to the frustrating mysteries raised by the film until much later – if ever. Which is to be expected when the screenplay was co-written by one of the guys behind Lost.

Delayed gratification aside, the flick is generally a success. It’s unquestionably gorgeous to look at, with some awe-inspiring shots of waterfalls and caves on our planet, along with computer-created looks at other worlds and species that are practically photorealistic. As such, seeing it in 3D is a must – something you’ll rarely hear me say – because it was actually filmed with the format in mind and Scott clearly knows how to employ it. It’s up there with Avatar and Hugo as one of the best uses of the technology.

Story-wise, things get a bit iffier. The plot kicks off with a couple of promising elements, but they’re eventually squandered by the above-mentioned case of sequel-itis. We’re introduced to the world of Prometheus through a prologue that seems to take place on Earth hundreds of thousands of years ago.

A snow-skinned, hulking humanoid stands above a raging waterfall as a spaceship hovers above him. He holds a strange black liquid in his hands, which he promptly downs like a shot of booze. The being immediately collapses, goes over the falls and breaks into pieces. Consider my interest piqued.

Fast-forward a few eons, where we briefly witness scientists Elizabeth Shaw (Noomi Rapace) and Charlie Holloway (Logan Marshall-Green) discover an ancient cave painting confirming that early man was visited by extraterrestrials. One more fast-forward (another decade or so) and we’re in the main part of the storyline. Shaw, Holloway and several other scientists are onboard the space vessel Prometheus, heading to a galaxy they believe is home to the beings who visited Earth all those years ago.

However, other crewmembers have missions that are less scientific in nature, including an enigmatic android named David (Michael Fassbender) and Meredith Vickers (Charlize Theron), the corporate executive financing the expedition. One of the film’s many mysteries is how the competing agendas will come into conflict. And will that even matter once Prometheus arrives at its destination and the team begins to encounter some less-than-welcoming creatures?

Despite a muddled screenplay from Jon Spaihts and Damon Lindeolof, Prometheus is Scott’s best film in years. (Take that with a grain of salt, as Scott hasn’t exactly been cranking out the classics lately.) It’s nowhere near an Alien-level classic, but I appreciate the attempt to make a sci-fi thriller that’s as much about life’s big questions as it is gory kills.

Now if Scott was concerned with actually trying to answer those questions, the grade at the bottom of this page might’ve been a little higher. Even a lackluster attempt would’ve been better than a maddening “wait for the sequel.” And while his eye for astounding visuals is indisputable, after a while it feels like he’s using that to overcompensate for a script that needed another few revisions to weed out the plot holes and unnecessary characters.

Even as the crew of the Prometheus is introduced, it’s obvious most of them are there as alien chow. It’s only a matter of who goes when. The leads do solid work, even if it feels like they’re overcompensating for underdeveloped characters.

Take Idris Elba, who plays Janek, the ship’s pilot. He’s only in a handful of scenes, but he makes Janek so affable that you can’t help but smile whenever he’s on the screen. It’s only later that you realize you still know jack-squat about the guy.

The same goes for Theron’s character, who the actress clearly understands better than the script does. The film paints her as a shadowy villain, even though her behavior seems perfectly reasonable under the insanely dangerous circumstances. Rapace is adequate in the lead role, but she never fully conveys Shaw’s supposed brilliance or why she would continue to associate with certain characters once spoiler-laden revelations are disclosed.

Still, everyone pales in comparison to Fassbender, whose astonishing work as David the android turns a $250 million blockbuster into a one-man show. The actor is so often the best part of the movies he stars in (Shame, X-Men: First Class, Haywire) that I'm running out of adjectives to describe his talent.

I could watch an entire movie chronicling how David keeps himself busy on the ship while everyone else hibernates. The brief glimpses we get of him shooting hoops, riding a bike and modeling his behavior on Lawrence of Arabia are fascinating. I also liked seeing how he modulates the character’s behavior based on the treatment he receives from those around him. He’s a totally different “person” around the android-averse than he is when interacting with those who treat him as an equal.

While Prometheus is ultimately not as brilliant as I’d hoped, it’s worth recommending based on some powerful performances and astonishing special effects. Just don’t get your hopes up for a follow-up that answers all of your questions. This thing will have to be a colossal hit for a sequel to even be considered, and I don’t see that happening.

Prometheus is rated R for sci-fi violence including some intense images, and brief language.

Grade: B-

Comments