REVIEW: Lawless

Courtesy of The Weinstein Company
Lawless, the new drama from director John Hillcoat, doesn’t have a chief protagonist, but there’s no doubt who audiences will be raving about as they leave the theater. Whether by design or through sheer force of will, the movie is an absolute showcase for Tom Hardy.

This has been a great year for the actor, who delivered memorable performances in the underrated This Means War and The Dark Knight Rises. But Hardy’s work in Lawless should establish him as a bona fide leading man. He evokes the tough guys of classic Hollywood, brooding slabs of meat that were inexplicably replaced by wispy heroes like Tom Cruise and Johnny Depp.

No offense to those guys – they’re both fine actors – but neither looks like he could take a punch in a real-world fistfight. Hardy, on the other hand, comes across as a genuine brawler. That impression adds a great deal of legitimacy to his role as Forrest Bondurant, the leader of a bootlegging family in Depression-era Virginia. When two bumbling policemen approach him sitting on the porch, then wince as he slowly rises out of his chair, you get why they’re skittish.

Though not the oldest brother, Forrest’s nature leaves little doubt as to why he’s in charge. His siblings, Howard (Jason Clarke) and Jack (Shia LaBeouf), brew the moonshine and make the deliveries, but they never forget that Forrest is the reason they’re raking in the cash.

Of course there’s no movie without conflict, so Nick Cave’s screenplay (based on “The Wettest County in the World,” Matt Bondurant’s historical novel about his own family) upends the brothers’ lives through the appearance of several outsiders. The first is Charlie Rakes (Guy Pearce), a preening enforcer brought in from Chicago to keep the town’s criminal element in line.

The others are Maggie Beauford (Jessica Chastain) and Bertha Minnix (Mia Wasikowska), two very different love interests for Forrest and Jack, respectively. Beauford also comes to town from Chicago, attempting to escape a past that keeps chasing her. Bertha is a local girl, but you can understand why her Mennonite minister father doesn’t want her spending time with the Bondurants. Still, Jack refuses to give up on her, even if that means putting her in the middle of dangerous situations she’s ill-prepared for.

When the brothers refuse to give in to Rakes’ demands, they ignite a battle of wills that escalates until the whole town is at war. Like all good gangster flicks, there’s a sense of inevitability about the proceedings. Still, you might be surprised by who is left standing when the smoke clears.

I’ve already raved about Hardy for several paragraphs, but he really is why you should see the movie. It’s also Hillcoat’s most crowd-pleasing film to date (The Proposition and The Road weren’t exactly feel-good pictures), thanks to plenty of outlandish performances and a satisfying conclusion. He can also direct the heck out of a fight scene.

Pearce makes Rakes eminently detestable, and you’ll be hoping for his gruesome demise from his first scene. Gary Oldman is awesome (when is he not?) as an over-the-top gangster, but it’s a glorified cameo. Always leave the audience wanting more, I guess.

Chastain doesn’t get much to do either, but she looks amazing doing it. Like Hardy, she’s on her way to becoming a major movie star. Also worth mentioning is Dane DeHaan, who plays Jack’s best friend and a sort of mascot for the Bondurants’ business. In just a handful of scenes, he endears the underwritten character to moviegoers. (He was very good in Chronicle earlier this year too.)

The only person who feels miscast is LaBeouf. Jack is an inexperienced hothead, a role the actor should be able to play in his sleep by now, but for some reason he doesn’t quite pull it off. With everyone else in the film, I was able to look past the performer and focus on the character he or she was playing. Anytime LaBeouf was onscreen, however, I just saw the kid from Transformers dressing up in gangster clothes.

That’s a considerable gripe considering the actor is in a sizable chunk of the movie. But the other actors, Hillcoat’s solid direction and Cave’s entertaining script helped me to get past it. There’s typically not much worth recommending this time of year, but Lawless makes the cut.

Lawless is rated R for strong bloody violence, language and some sexuality/nudity.

Grade: B

Comments