QUICK TAKES: Lee Daniels' The Butler, Kick-Ass 2 and Planes


Courtesy of The Weinstein Company
Lee Daniels’ The Butler
(Rated PG-13 for some violence and disturbing images, language, sexual material, thematic elements and smoking.)

Who’s in it: Forest Whitaker, Oprah Winfrey, David Oyelowo, Lenny Kravitz, Cuba Gooding Jr. and numerous actors in presidential cameos.

What it’s about: “Inspired” by a true story, the film tells the story of Cecil Gaines (Whitaker), a White House butler who served seven presidents over three decades. He’s a witness to history – from the Civil Rights Movement to Vietnam to fairness in the workplace – but his job also puts a strain on his relationships with his lonely wife (Winfrey) and activist son (Oyelowo).

The good: Most of the actors’ performances are terrific. Whitaker delivers his strongest work in years, bringing warmth, sadness and anger to a character that could’ve easily been a caricature. From her first scene, Winfrey comes across as Gaines’ frustrated wife rather than one of the planet’s most influential women. It’s a nice reminder that she was a gifted actress before she was OPRAH. I would be shocked if she doesn’t get a Best Supporting Actress nomination. Oyelowo continues to be one of the most compelling aspects of the projects he chooses. Kravitz and Gooding are also strong as Gaines’ co-workers. On the presidential front, James Marsden and Minka Kelly, who play the Kennedys, are the most convincing.

The not-so-good: Everyone else that Daniels cast in political roles. Robin Williams doesn’t register as Eisenhower; John Cusack is terribly miscast as Nixon; Liev Schreiber is too young to pass as LBJ; and Alan Rickman is reduced to a bad wig and a weird accent as Reagan. Jane Fonda makes a surprisingly decent Nancy, but she’s onscreen for less than two minutes. The makeup is awful, often causing unintended laughter from the audience. Danny Strong’s script completely fictionalizes the main character and his family (for instance, the real butler’s name was Eugene Allen, he had a much different childhood than the film depicts and his relationships with his wife and son weren’t contentious), and the plot is a retread of Forrest Gump. Daniels’ direction makes it seem like he made three separate movies – all with different goals, themes and tones – and jammed them together at the last minute.

Grade: B-


Courtesy of Universal
Kick-Ass 2
(Rated R for strong violence, pervasive language, crude and sexual content, and brief nudity.)

Who’s in it: Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Chloe Grace Moretz, Christopher Mintz-Plasse and Jim Carrey.

What it’s about: A few years after the events of the first film, Dave Lizewski (Taylor-Johnson) misses the excitement that comes with being the titular superhero. As does Mindy Macready (Moretz), who – after the death of her father – is attempting to be a normal teenager instead of the ultra-violent Hit Girl. They get their chance to suit up again when former colleague Red Mist (Mintz-Plasse) decides to become the world’s first supervillain, complete with a name that I can’t type without getting fired. To take down Dave’s old friend, they team up with Justice Forever, a league of wannabe superheroes led by Colonel Stars and Stripes (Carrey).

The good: Like last time, Moretz is hands-down the best thing about the flick. Hit Girl shouldn’t work as a realistic character, but the gifted young actress makes Macready’s conflicted feelings and budding humanity seem authentic. Carrey is very good as the film’s sole moral compass, but it’s a far smaller role than the film’s marketing would have you believe. There are a handful of genuinely funny lines.

The not-so-good: Basically everything else. The film is basically a reboot with the same cast. Other than a couple of major deaths, nothing from the first film sticks. New writer-director Jeff Wadlow has none of the visual panache or flair for dialogue that Matthew Vaughn and Jane Goldman brought to the original. His attempts at being shocking or “edgy” (a meaningless buzzword) come across like a 10-year-old who just learned the f-word. It also seems like Wadlow doesn’t know if he’s making a comedic version of a superhero flick or a genuine one, so he tries unsuccessfully to do both. Taylor-Johnson barely registers, even though he’s supposedly the main character. Lizewski doesn’t grow or change in any way (aside from getting more buff); he just coasts through the movie.

Grade: C


Courtesy of Disney
Planes
(Rated PG for some mild action and rude humor.)

Who’s in it: The voices of Dane Cook, Stacy Keach, Brad Garrett and Teri Hatcher.

What it’s about: Dusty Crophopper (Cook) is a crop-duster plane with a fear of heights and impossible dreams of being a racer. To his friends’ disbelief, he somehow qualifies to compete in the Wings Across the World race. With the help Skipper (Keach), a former combat plane, he learns the skills he’ll need to succeed in his dangerous but rewarding endeavor.

The good: Cook, who I typically find smug and irritating, is genuinely likable as Dusty. His voice communicates the character’s good-natured personality and sense of wonder as he travels around the globe. He also effectively portrays Dusty’s maturation over the course of the race. The rest of the cast does solid vocal work as well. Fans of Top Gun will appreciate the in-joke that kicks off the movie. As with all Cars-related properties, the animation is welcoming and colorful.

The not-so-good: Planes commits the cardinal sin of kid’s movies – it’s boring (the second act in particular). I noticed many of the children in my screening growing increasingly antsy, and a few families even got up and left. It’s bizarre how similar the plot is to the recently released Turbo. Replace the planes with snails and racecars and it’s basically the same movie, down to the climactic race at the end.

Grade: C

Comments