REVIEW: Whiplash


Courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics
As a college English teacher, I understand how thin the line is between pushing students to live up to their potential and being so hard on them that they collapse under the weight of expectations. You have to be firm to get them to take the class seriously, particularly since many students come from a high school environment where they got straight-A’s in their sleep, while also allowing time for kids to adjust to a change in difficulty so they don’t immediately crash and burn.

But there’s a vast difference between cultivating talent through discipline and being a dictator who delights in psychological abuse. It’s a concept that writer-director Damien Chazelle examines in Whiplash, an astonishing gut-punch of a character study that unfolds like a horror movie. But instead of a masked, machete-wielding maniac, the antagonist is a brilliant, sadistic music instructor who pushes his students to the brink of insanity to cultivate extraordinary performances. I guarantee it will appear on my Best of 2014 list.

Miles Teller (one of this generation’s most promising actors) plays Andrew Neiman, an ambitious jazz drummer who attends the prestigious Shaffer Conservatory of Music (a fictional stand-in for Julliard). His dreams of becoming an all-time great, and he plays every night until his fingers bleed to make sure that happens.

During a particularly brutal practice session, he looks up from his drum set to see Terence Fletcher (J.K. Simmons), Shaffer’s most revered – and feared – conductor, standing in the doorway. This sudden appearance marks the beginning of a mesmerizing partnership that becomes the sole focus of Andrew’s existence, to the detriment of his relationships with his father (Paul Reiser) and his new girlfriend (Melissa Benoist). All aspects of his life that aren’t music-related melt away in pursuit of his descent into madness or an ascent into greatness, depending on your perspective.

When it comes to analyzing Whiplash, I have to be honest: I’m trying my best to put the rest of this review into words instead of just typing 20 lines of exclamation marks. I can’t remember the last time I had such a visceral reaction to a film. There’s a beat in the last scene of the film – involving Teller’s character hitting his cymbal at a precise moment – that made me lean forward in my seat with my mouth hanging open. It’s incredibly powerful, and the music communicates all the emotions. It was all I could do to refrain from cheering.

Stuff like that is what makes the movie so great; Chazelle wisely directs the focus of every technical aspect of filmmaking toward the two central powerhouse performances, highlighting just how special they are – just observe the frequent whip pans as the camera moves back and forth between the characters.

Teller continues to prove why he’s one of my favorite young actors with his depiction of Andrew. He completely sells the character’s transformation from a kid who can’t even make eye contact with a cute girl to a confident, aggressive hothead who shuts down a family dinner by verbally destroying his father’s friends.

That’s due to the unparalleled chemistry Teller has with his co-star. Simmons is too amazing for words, delivering his greatest performance in a career filled with brilliant work. He’s absolutely terrifying (and often blisteringly funny at the same time), but there’s no denying the results of Fletcher’s methods.

Even more compelling, Chazelle doesn’t make him a total monster. Late in the film, there’s a scene where the teacher unpacks his philosophy for Andrew and he’s dangerously persuasive. He’s so powerful, so charismatic, that he can utter the phrase, “there are no two words in the English language more harmful than ‘good job’” and you totally buy it.

Current buzz has Whiplash as a Best Picture contender and Simmons as a shoo-in for a Best Supporting Actor nomination, but Teller is equally worthy of recognition. I can’t recommend the film highly enough. It’s one of the most thrilling experiences I’ve had in a theater this year.

Whiplash is rated R for strong language including some sexual references.

Grade: A

Comments