REVIEW: In the Heart of the Sea

Courtesy of Warner Bros.
In the Heart of the Sea, Ron Howard’s take on the true story that inspired Herman Melville’s fictional Moby Dick, is a throwback to seafaring adventures of another era. However, it ends up being incredibly riveting and authentic thanks to modern advances in filmmaking technology. Marrying the two different tones and styles must’ve been difficult, but Howard and his screenwriter, Charles Leavitt, transform them into a surprisingly effective piece of entertainment.

What’s more, I genuinely enjoyed watching the movie in 3D, something I don’t say too often. It makes sense, considering that some of Howard’s previous work proves he knows his way around CGI. He has experience using technology to enhance his story, which is so much better than adding bells and whistles solely to pad the film’s bottom line.

The story (based on Nathaniel Philbrick’s book) is fairly straightforward, depicting the stunning tale of the Essex, a whaling ship brought down by one of the very creatures it set out to hunt. As with most tragedies, emotions like greed, pride and envy result in a disaster that kills several people.

In the Heart of the Sea opens with Melville (Ben Whishaw), seeking inspiration, begging to interview the last surviving crew member of the Essex. Tom Nickerson (Brendan Gleeson) is an older man now, clearly haunted by the demons of his past. After some coaxing from his wife (Michelle Fairley), the former whaler begins to unburden his soul.

His story begins off the coast of Nantucket in the summer of 1819. As the Essex prepares for its journey across the sea, the vessel’s experienced first mate, Owen Chase (Chris Hemsworth), and its untested captain, George Pollard (Benjamin Walker), find themselves in a battle of wills. Their quest for power leads the ship and its crew into a crippling storm, and then into rarely-traveled waters home to the great beast that marks their ship for destruction.

And that’s just the first half of the movie. After that, viewers experience the aftermath of the Essex’s sinking, as the surviving crew squeezes into three tiny lifeboats and brave months stranded at sea. They must brave storms, starvation, panic and despair, all because they chased their greed to places they were specifically warned not to go.

I’ll admit In the Heart of the Sea gets off to a shaky start. The initial bookend segment, which you’ve seen in countless other movies, seemed like a tired way to tell the story. Fortunately, Whishaw (nearly unrecognizable) and Gleeson are phenomenal actors who elevate the material and instill their characters with compelling personalities.

I was also nervous in the first couple of flashback scenes, which contain some distressingly cartoonish CGI and Hemsworth trying out a laughably terrible New England accent. But after the first 20 minutes or so, the scenery starts looking more realistic and Hemsworth adopts the generic American accent that British and Australian actors traditionally utilize. (If you choose to see the movie in 3D, that’s also about the time your body gets over that fake-seasick feeling.)

Once the second act kicks in, my uneasiness disappeared and I began to enjoy the old-school adventure story (which seems to be making a comeback between this film and next month’s The Revenant) and the melodramatic acting showcase. Hemsworth and Walker (a Cartersville native with local roots) are great together, both doing their best to establish reasonable motivations for why Chase and Pollard – both highly unlikable at times – would behave as they do.

I appreciated the screenplay’s insistence on making Pollard an actual character, rather than a stereotypical bad guy. It would’ve been a lot easier to portray him as a cartoon villain, but eliminating Pollard’s own fears and insecurities would’ve erased any sense of nuance and hurt the story.

The rest of the supporting cast is also strong, especially the engaging Cillian Murphy (in a rare non-psycho role) as Chase’s oldest friend; Tom Holland (future Spider-Man) as the fresh-faced, teenage version of Nickerson; and Fairley as Nickerson’s no-nonsense wife. Howard also makes the whaling scenes absolutely riveting, particularly the stunning attack that serves as the film’s biggest setpiece. Looks like he remembered some of the kinetic techniques he utilized for Rush, his massively underappreciated 2013 racing drama that also starred Hemsworth.

In the Heart of the Sea probably won’t end up on many critic’s Top 10 lists in the coming weeks, but it’s a thrilling adventure story that’s definitely worth seeing on the big screen. And if it inspires a few people to pick up Melville’s classic novel for the first time, even better.

In the Heart of the Sea is rated PG-13 for intense sequences of action and peril, brief startling violence, and thematic material.

Grade: B

Comments