REVIEW: Hail, Caesar!

Courtesy of Universal
Anyone familiar with Joel and Ethan Coen’s work knows that the filmmaking duo isn’t interested in mainstream appeal. Sure, many of their movies – like Fargo, No Country for Old Men, O Brother, Where Art Thou? and True Grit – are award winners and box office hits. But others – like A Serious Man, Burn After Reading and the masterful Inside Llewyn Davis – are often strange, deceptively understated or impenetrable to audiences who don’t know what they’re in for.

I’ve got a feeling Hail, Caesar!, the Coen brothers’ latest collaboration, is going to fall into that second category. I absolutely loved the movie, but it seems like it was made for me and six other people. Not exactly blockbuster material. That doesn’t make it bad; in fact, I laughed so hard that I had a pounding headache by the time I left the theater. But humor is highly subjective, and something tells me many viewers will leave ticked off or scratching their heads. Take that as a warning or a recommendation, whichever you prefer.

Hail, Caesar! introduces viewers to Eddie Mannix (Josh Brolin), a fixer for Capitol Pictures during Hollywood’s 1950s heyday. When the studio’s stars – who are supposed to be squeaky clean and wholesome – find themselves in a compromising position, it’s up to Mannix to solve the problem, usually with a briefcase full of money or by schmoozing the right reporter.

When Baird Whitlock (George Clooney), the studio’s biggest movie star, is abducted right before he’s supposed to shoot a pivotal scene in an expensive biblical epic, Mannix has to uncover the kidnappers’ motive. He must also deal with his typical daily headaches, including a temperamental director (Ralph Fiennes) and his inexperienced actor (Alden Ehrenreich); a starlet (Scarlett Johansson) whose pregnancy could ignite a scandal; feuding gossip reporters who are also twin sisters (Tilda Swinton times two); and a singing, dancing matinee idol with a few secrets of his own (Channing Tatum).

As convoluted as that narrative sounds on the surface, with its multitude of characters and plenty of mysteries to be solved, the story turns out to be relatively simple. Honestly, the short version of the movie’s plot can be boiled down to “what if Trumbo was good?”

But that doesn’t make Hail, Caesar! any less entertaining; it’s a farcical exercise that evokes the movie industry’s Golden Age, complete with gorgeous imagery that looks like it was shot in Technicolor. Of course, it’s darn near impossible for a film to look ugly when Roger Deakins is the cinematographer.

It’s also a blast to watch wonderful actors put their egos aside to look ridiculous and deliver the Coens’ remarkable dialogue. The duo once again uses Clooney’s talent for playing idiots to their advantage. Whitlock is a bumbling doofus, and his reaction upon learning why he was abducted is both hilarious and unexpectedly subversive. The same goes for Tatum’s role as a Gene Kelly-esque hoofer. Hail, Caesar! might be the best use of the actor’s talents since he shocked everyone with his comedic chops in 21 Jump Street.

Brolin is also quite good in a role that’s tougher than it seems on the surface. It’s hard to be the straight man when everyone around you gets to have fun acting crazy and over-the-top, but he makes it work. That’s particularly true in one of the final scenes, as he reacts with dawning horror at the ramifications of a monologue delivered by Clooney’s character.

Folks like Johansson, Fiennes and Swinton don’t show up for long (heck, Jonah Hill is featured prominently in the marketing materials but he’s literally in the movie for less than three minutes), but they make the most of their limited screen time. Each of them is funny, memorable and committed to the absurdity of the material.

But I was most impressed with Ehrenreich, who plays a goodhearted cowboy actor out of his element in a period drama. He doesn’t have much to do with the film’s major plot, but he’s got a magnetic screen presence and solid chemistry with Brolin and Fiennes.

Again, Hail, Caesar! definitely isn’t for everyone. But my still-pounding head can confirm that I had a great time. Thank goodness we’re out of the January garbage dump and back into the land of interesting films.

Hail, Caesar! is rated PG-13 for some suggestive content and smoking.

Grade: A-

Comments