REVIEW: Hell or High Water

Courtesy of Lionsgate
I’ll get right to the point: this extraordinarily intense modern western, which I hadn’t even heard of until a few weeks ago, is one of the best films of 2016. Unfortunately, its limited release strategy means it’s only playing in a handful of Atlanta theaters. You’ll have to put in a little extra effort to experience this gripping, darkly funny tale, but I promise it’s worth the drive. I’m already making plans to see it again.

Reminiscent of the Coen brothers’ No Country for Old Men, director David Mackenzie and screenwriter Taylor Sheridan (Sicario) tell the story of a divorced dad (Chris Pine) and his ex-con brother (Ben Foster) who resort to robbing banks to save the family’s West Texas farm. Hot on their tails is a shrewd cop on the verge of retirement (Jeff Bridges, channeling his version of Rooster Cogburn) and his long-suffering partner (Gil Birmingham).

That’s essentially the whole plot, though part of the fun is discovering the underlying messages, both subtle and not-so-much. Let’s just say the film and most of its characters – on both sides of the law – don’t have much sympathy for the banks. Plus, you get the impression that bystanders are probably rooting for the robbers they think of as present-day Robin Hoods. If they happen to cross paths with them, though…well, almost everybody’s carrying a gun in Texas.

Clocking in at a lean 102 minutes, Hell or High Water weaves a straightforward yet complex narrative that isn’t interested in the standard cops and robbers tropes. Each of the four main characters is interesting and significant (although Foster’s hothead, while solidly acted, is the most clichéd), meaning the movie makes it almost impossible for the audience to choose sides for most of the running time.

The harrowing third act ultimately makes the choice less difficult, but the absolutely perfect conclusion reinstates a gut-wrenching sense of ambiguity. As the end credits roll, chances are you’ll still be arguing with yourself about who was “right” in that final conversation.

The performances are outstanding, especially Pine. He’s spent so much time in the blockbuster world that I forgot what a phenomenal character actor he is. As the conflicted heart of the story, this is easily the best work he’s ever done.

Bridges is fantastic as well; he’s not stepping outside his comfort zone by any stretch of the imagination, but his world-weary cop is a persona that audiences have grown to love. Still, the film’s surprise MVP is Birmingham, whose deadpan delivery as his character shoulders the boss’ loving abuse is both endearing and admirable.

As we rapidly approach the fall movie season, the oncoming flood of Oscar bait will have to work pretty hard to wrestle a spot away from Hell of High Water on my 10 Best List. It reminded me why I love going to the movies in the first place.

Hell or High Water is rated R for some strong violence, language throughout and brief sexuality.

Grade: A

Comments